Tuesday, July 2, 2013

How The Guardian Twisted President Correa's Comments on Snowden

See Updates below.

The following text shows how the Guardian updated their story about an interview with Ecuador's President Correa after it was already widely published. Original story: http://archive.is/h10ae Updated version: http://archive.is/UoHmY
Rafael Correa says Ecuador helped Edward not considering Snowden by mistake
Byasylum: helping him was a 'mistake'

Ecuador's president reveals travel pass was granted 'without authorisation' and says whistleblower is now Russia's problem

    Rory Carroll, The Guardian
Monday, in Quito
    guardian.co.uk, Tuesday 2 July 1, 2013 21:27 EDT
Ecuadorian President 11.44 AEST    

Rafael Correa at the Moncloa Palace in Madrid (AFP)
Topics:Ecuador president Edward Snowden ? Rafael Correa

Ecuador's president Rafael Correa said Snowden 'must be on Ecuadorean territory' to make an asylum request. Photograph: Martin Mejia/AP

Ecuador is not considering Edward Snowden’sSnowden's asylum request and never intended to facilitate his flight from Hong Kong, president Rafael Correa said as the whistleblower made a personal plea to Quito for his case to be heard.

Snowden was Russia’sRussia's responsibility and would have to reach Ecuadorean territory before the country would consider any asylum request, the president said in an interview with the Guardian on Monday.

"Are we responsible for getting him to Ecuador? It’sIt's not logical. The country that has to give him a safe conduct document is Russia.”."

The president, speaking to the Guardian at the presidential palace in Quito, said his government did not intentionally help Snowden travel from Hong Kong to Moscow with a temporary travel pass. "It was a mistake on our part,”," he added.

Asked if he thought the former NSA contractor would ever make it to Quito, he replied: "Mr Snowden's situation is very complicated, but in this moment he is in Russian territory and these are decisions for the Russian authorities."

On whether Correa would like to meet him, the president said: "Not particularly. He's a very complicated person. Strictly speaking, Mr Snowden spied for some time."

The comments clashedcontrasted with expressions of gratitude the 30-year-old fugitive issued hours later, before Correa’sCorrea's views had been published.

"I must express my deep respect for your principles and sincere thanks for your government’sgovernment's action in considering my request for political asylum,”," Snowden said, according to a letter, written in Spanish and attributed to Snowden.

obtained by the Press Association news agency, based in London.

"There are few world leaders who would risk standing for the human rights of an individual against the most powerful government on earth, and the bravery of Ecuador and its people is an example to the world.”

The former NSA contractor contrasted."

Snowden compared the silence of governments afraid of US retaliation with Ecuador’sEcuador's help in his flight to Moscow on 22 June. A temporary Ecuadorean travel document substituted for his cancelled US passport.

"The decisive action of your consul in London, Fidel Narvaez, guaranteed my rights would be protected upon departing Hong Kong – I could never have risked travel without that. Now, as a result, and through the continued support of your government, I remain free and able to publish information that serves the public interest.”."

The letter will boost Ecuador’sEcuador's reputation with Snowden’sSnowden's supporters but sat awkwardly with the president’spresident's attempt to distance Quito from the saga. Correa said Quito respected the right of asylum and appreciated Snowden exposing the extent of US spying, but willwould not consider an asylum request unless he made it to an Ecuadorean embassy or the country itself – a remote possibility while he remains reportedly marooned in Sheremetyevo airport’sairport's transit lounge. "He must be on Ecuadorean territory,”," the president said.

Earlier on Monday, Moscow confirmed that Snowden had applied for asylum in Russia. The Los Angeles Times said he had made similar applications to a total of 15 countries. In another statement, issued through by the campaigning website Wikileaks, Snowden attacked President Obama for putting pressure behind on the scens on countries to which he had petitioned for asylum.

In his Guardian interview, Correa addedsaid his government had not, and would not, give Snowden an authorised travel document to extract himself from theMoscow airport. "The right of asylum request is one thing but helping someone travel from one country to another — Ecuador has never done this. "

He said the temporary travel document issued by his London consul on 22 June – and publicly disowned five days later — was a blunder.

"It was a mistake on our part. Look, this crisis hit us in a very vulnerable moment. Our foreign minister was touring Asia. Our deputy foreign minister was in the Czech Republic. Our US ambassador was in Italy.”."

Narvaez and Julian Assange, the WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange, who has sheltered at Ecuador’sEcuador's London embassy for the past year to escape extradition, took matters into their own hands because they feared Snowden risked capture, said Correa.


"The consul, in his desperation, probably he couldn’tcouldn't reach the foreign minister, it was four in the morning, ... and he issued a safe conduct document without validity, without authorisation, without us even knowing.”

The president said Narvaez would be “sanctioned” but that he understood the consul and Assange acted in good faith. Quito’s appreciation for Assange had not been damaged, he said.

Correa said the consul was a "cultured" man who cited the example of Ecuadorean diplomats in Czechoslovakia giving Jews visas in defiance of their foreign ministry during the second world war.

"Look, he [Assange] is in the embassy, he's a friend of the consul, and he calls him at four in the morning to say they are going to capture Snowden. The [consul] is desperate – 'how are we going to save the life of this man?' – and does it.

"So I told him: OK, if you think you did the right thing, I respect your decision, but you could not give, without authorisation, that safe conduct pass. It was completely invalid, and he will have to accept the consequences."

Narvaez would be "sanctioned", the president said, without elaborating.

Some Ecuadorean diplomats have complained that Assange appeared to usurp Quito but the president said there was no rupture. "Mr Assange continues to enjoy our total respect and is under the protection of the Ecuadorean state."

Correa, a standard bearer for the left in Latin America, has joined European and other Latin Americans leaders in denouncing US espionage.

However he softened his denunciations of the UStone over the weekend and praised vice -president Joe Biden for a gracious phone call, saying he would consider Washington’sWashington's request to refuse any asylum claim from Snowden while retaining Ecuador’sEcuador's sovereignty. Asked if he thought Snowden would ever make it to Quito, he said he did not know.

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News and Media 2013
Update 1: Most of this is just standard editorial revision, including some legal input to soften the denunciations "tone". There are significant additions, perhaps because the full transcript was not ready when rushed to press.

The heading is perhaps the most interesting change: instead of "helping Snowden by mistake", it says that "helping Snowden WAS a mistake". That is a significant difference. And in fact Correa never explicitly states it.

Does Correa really believe it was a mistake to help Snowden? He only says a mistake was made when the consul helped him. For all we know, he is secretly quite proud of his Consul's actions.

Update 2: After concerted complaints from President Correa on Twitter, the Guardian has changed it's headline yet again: "Ecuador says it blundered over Snowden travel document."

Correa also notes that  he said Snowden is "in a complicated SITUATION." Guardian translated that as: "He is a complicated PERSON".

And Correa notes that while Guardian has belatedly rectified their story, all the newswires who spread these distortions around the world have not.

Update 3: Here is Prez. Correa's original interview with Guardian in Spanish (vid) and an English translation:

Update 4: Professor Marcello Ferrada de Noli has posted some excellent analysis of what President Correa actually said compared to what The Guardian wrote.

1 comment:

  1. Welcome to Me N Roll
    Welcome to Me N Roll, a hub of Fusion food in Japanese and western food. Here you can get food of your own choice and taste. Rice Wines, sake and freshly prepared Western and Asian food is available all the time.

    Go to>> http://www.menroll.com.au/